6° F

Wineke: Are we really worst in race achievement gap results?

Published On: Nov 14 2013 09:20:22 PM CST
classroom education school generic

Well, this ought to be embarrassing: The National Assessment of Educational Progress has looked at the gap between African American and white American students and determined the difference between black school achievement and white school achievement is greater in Wisconsin than in any other state in the union.

When educational achievement is measured in terms of reading and math, we are the worst in the nation, behind Mississippi. Think about that: We rank below Mississippi.

What all this means, I’m not exactly sure. I suppose it might be that white kids in Mississippi don’t learn very much, either, so the achievement gap is less pronounced. That could be it, but I don’t think I’d take too much comfort in that explanation.

Or, I suppose we could blame it all on Milwaukee. Except that when high school graduation rates are compared, Madison has a greater gap between black and white than Milwaukee.

I don’t know how we compare with Mississippi. I don’t want to ever have to compare Wisconsin to Mississippi.

As much as I’d like to blame it all on Gov. Scott Walker, it is painfully obvious that the problem didn’t start in 2011 when he took office.

My real problem is that no one outside the educational establishment and a handful of African American leaders seems to care. No one seems to see it as a crisis that must involve every citizen of the state. And that might be indicative of an even scarier problem -- is it just possible that Wisconsin is not the great state we have lulled ourselves into thinking it is?

I mean, we did manage to elect Walker governor not once but twice if you count the recall -- and how can you not count the recall? In his first campaign, he promised to end high-speed rail in the state and curb benefits for state employees. In the recall, he gloried in having achieved those dubious ends.

I don’t blame the governor for setting us on a new path toward mediocrity; I do blame us for endorsing that path. And for providing him with a Republican Senate and Assembly to join him in rolling back every policy that set Wisconsin apart from mediocrity.

Our government is our creation. It reflects who we are. We might try thinking about that.

Our schools are our creation, too. They reflect who we are as a people, what we value, what we strive to achieve. And if we’re sanguine about having a racial achievement gap that places us behind Mississippi and every other state in the union, well that says something about our values.

And what it says is not very encouraging.

  • PHOTOS: Uber-cute puppies on tour

    A basket of puppies arrived at the News 3 studio in Madison Friday morning as part of a promotion between Uber Madison and a Madison-based pet rescue. Uber and teamed up to offer a puppy break to Uber app users that benefits the pet rescue. Condi (brown) and Wylie (black) got lots of snuggles and love from staff before they went on their way to cheer up other Madisonians through Uber until 3 p.m., the company said.

  • GOP group at debate

    Scott Olson/Getty Image

    2016 presidential candidates' net worth

    Ever wonder just what a presidential candidate is worth? Take a look at the net worth estimates for each of the remaining Republican and Democratic candidates as compiled by Forbes.

  • Jim Gilmore

    Darren McCollester/Getty Images

    Election 2016: Who has dropped out

    Jim Gilmore became the latest 2016 presidential candidate to leave the race on Friday. Here's a look at him and the other former candidates who have also ended their campaigns.