Madison
44° F
Overcast
Overcast
Advertisement

Wineke: Non-violence is a non-starter for Rush Limbaugh

Published On: Jan 21 2013 01:08:16 AM CST

The Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s might have been a lot more effective if African-Americans had only had the good sense to abandon non-violence, radio personality Rush Limbaugh suggests.

"If a lot of African-Americans back in the 60s had guns and the legal right to use them for self-defense, you think they would have needed Selma?" Limbaugh asked.

"I don’t know. I’m just asking. If John Lewis, who says he was beat upside the head, if John Lewis had had a gun, would he have been beat upside the head on that bridge?"

Limbaugh, of course, is opposed to gun control measures. John Lewis, a civil rights icon who is now a Congressman from Georgia, was beaten during the legendary march from Selma, Ala.,  to Montgomery for voting rights legislation in 1965. He didn't say he was beaten, he suffered a concussion.

But that’s neither here nor there. Limbaugh is raising a question that has been recurring with disturbing frequency on the part of right wing agitators during the past few weeks: Would America's race problem have been resolved more easily if African-Americans had had weapons?

It is a particularly stupid question, but it is a question worth considering.

Would John Lewis have been beaten if he had been carrying a gun on that march?

No, he would not have been beaten. He would have been killed.

These marchers were up against the police establishment of the State of Alabama. They were attacked by police dogs. They were beaten savagely. Does Limbaugh honestly think that Gov. George Wallace would have hesitated to order his troops to open fire if the marchers started brandishing weapons?

Not only would Lewis have been killed, but the segregationists would have used the conflict to deny credibility to the entire movement. There would have been no Civil Rights Movement.

The genius of Martin Luther King, Jr. and his colleagues was to build the moral credibility of their cause through the use of non-violence. They followed the teachings of Ghandi – and the teachings of Jesus – to suffer violence but not respond in kind.

There were certainly people who thought that was a weak position. People like Limbaugh who worship power and call it principle would never understand.

But, in the end, it was Martin Luther King and John Lewis who prevailed. King was assassinated, but the Voting Rights Act became the law of the land – though it is once more under attack. The Rush Limbaughs of the 1960s crawled back under their rocks.

I expect the current Limbaugh is losing his audience, too. It’s about time. He’s not only wrong, he is stupid.

Advertisement
  • PHOTOS: 27 tons of documents destroyed during BBB Shredfest 2016

    The free BBB Shredfest event Saturday offered anyone with documents containing personal information to shred up to three bags. Destroying documents is one way to protect one's identity and thwart fraudsters.

    More than 1,600 cars stopped by two Madison locations from 8:30 a.m. to 11 a.m. Saturday, and 27 tons of documents were shredded, a Better Business Bureau representative said. The sites were at SVA Certified Public Accountants, 1221 John Q Hammons Dr. and Warner Park, 2930 N. Sherman Ave.

  • Elise Romas

    PHOTOS: Thousands take part in 34th annual CrazyLegs 2016

    The 34th annual CrazyLegs Classic 8K Run and 2-mile Walk Saturday raised money for UW Athletics. As of Friday night, 13,000 people had signed up to participate, and organizers expected more to register Saturday morning before the race begins in waves at 11 a.m.

    WINNERS: Pat Jenkins, 24, of Cambridge, is the top finisher in the men's category. UW law student Jessa Hackman, 24, of Madison, is the top female finisher.

Advertisement