48° F
Light Rain
Light Rain

Wineke: A crisis in Catholicism

Published On: Feb 25 2013 10:41:37 AM CST

Pope Benedict XV1 enters his final week as the world’s only absolute monarch this week and the 100 or so Roman Catholic cardinals who share in the church’s leadership are preparing to choose his successor.

In doing so, they will find – I expect – both tactical and strategic challenges.

As in any organization, the tactical decisions those cardinals make will make the news and the strategic decisions will make the difference.

The tactical decision is relatively easy: The cardinals will choose a new pope. In  theory, they could choose almost anyone; in practice, they will choose someone from among their small number. And they will choose someone who pretty closely reflects Benedict’s philosophy. They will do so because he had a hand in elevating them to their present positions of honor.

The strategic decisions are far more difficult. The cardinals will take the first steps toward determining whether the underlying theological concepts of the church still make sense.

The church may not be facing unprecedented challenges – we don’t have competing popes, for example, though we did the last time a pope resigned his office. The church may not be facing unprecedented challenges but it surely is facing an unprecedented communications environment.

Any problem the church encounters today becomes headline news all over the world within minutes.

And there are a few problems out there. This week, the top prelate of the British Isles, Cardinal Keith O’Brien of Scotland, resigned after being accused of making unwanted sexual advances toward younger priests some years ago.

Cardinal Roger Mahoney of Los Angeles, plans to help vote on the next pope.  Documents released by the Archdiocese of Los Angeles during the past weeks show clearly that Mahoney not only helped cover up illegal actions by his priests but that he, in fact, knew they were illegal.

In addition, all sorts of financial and sexual scandals seem to be based in the Vatican itself.  This is not good.

But it’s not just publicity that makes all this a problem.  What makes it a problem is that the church considers ordination to be a sacrament. It sees being a priest, a bishop, a pope, as being called by God in a line of succession that traces back to Jesus himself.

If we find a relatively small number of priests being shielded from scrutiny by a relatively large number of bishops who, in turn, are protected by leaders at the highest levels of the hierarchy, then the entire fundamental theology of the priesthood is called into question – and if the legitimacy of the priesthood is called into question, then what is the legitimacy of the church, itself?

These questions will not be resolved by electing a pope who tweets.

But if the cardinals don’t deal with them, a few years from now, the troubles of today will seem like the good old days.

  • Isreali President Shimon Peres

    Ilia Yefimovich/Getty Images

    Notable deaths of 2016

    Here's a look at some of the celebrities we've lost so far in 2016.

  • PHOTOS: Madison store helps collect hundreds of Teddy bears for police

    MADISON, Wis.--A west Madison store is part of an effort to collect hundreds of stuffed animals to donate to six police departments in Southern Wisconsin.

    Todd Merryfield, owner of The Learning Shop at 714 S. Gammon Road, said the store is collecting the bears for officers who use them to help comfort children with whom police come in contact.

    "This is a great way to support what (police) do," Merryfield said. "Those are the kids that need something like this to reassure them, calm them down, and let them know that things are all right."

    Nearly 500 plush animals were donated Tuesday, a Learning Shop spokeswoman said. The Madison store's effort is part of a larger initiative through the Bears for Humanity organization. 

    Photos by Doug Wahl

  • Passport


    Mistakes people make when moving abroad

    Moving abroad? has put together a list of six mistakes people make when they're moving abroad. Click through, so you don't make the same mistakes during your move.