84° F
Scattered Clouds
Scattered Clouds

Sheriff: Middleton admitted woman's remains were in burn pit

Published On: Dec 24 2013 01:31:06 PM CST   Updated On: Nov 04 2013 08:31:51 PM CST

Investigators still on scene outside Evansville Monday, where female human remains found in a burn pit over the weekend.


An Evansville man admitted to police the remains of a missing Fitchburg woman could be found in a burn pit on his property, according to Rock County Sheriff Bob Spoden.

PHOTO GALLERY: Death investigation scene

Spoden said Nathan Middleton, 29, told Fitchburg police he had contact with 18-year-old Aprina Paul, who was reported missing last week. Middleton told police he had contacted Paul on the Internet, and that her remains could be found on his property.

“We do know that even from the statements Mr. Middleton gave, we do know they met through the Internet and that the relationship was brief in nature and wasn’t something that was long term; that they had just recently met. So we’re trying to confirm whether that is the case,” said Spoden.

Spoden said they don't know if Middleton played a role in Paul's death.

Rock County officials said bone fragments found in a burn pit at Middleton's residence have been determined to be female human remains. The coroner has not identified the remains. Spoden said bone fragments would be sent to a firm in Chicago to make an identification.

“Obviously I can tell you it’s concerning anytime someone goes to the length of burning a human body in a fire pit. It is not the normal response for anybody that has a health condition or passes on in your company, so that itself is very troubling,” said Spoden.

Rock County sheriff's deputies have seized numerous items on the property, including items they believe belonged to Paul, according to Spoden. He said some of Paul's property was found in a burn barrel on the property.

Detectives are still looking for Paul's cellphone and continue to interview Middleton.

“We are going to do everything we can at the sheriff’s office and the coroner’s office to bring some justice to this family, and hopefully some closure so they can move on with their lives,” said Spoden.

Middleton is currently being held at the Rock County Jail on a probation violation.

Middleton’s fiancé talked with WISC-TV Monday night.

She said she was not aware of Paul being in their home until Middleton confessed to her last week that he burned Paul’s body on a bonfire in their yard.

Middleton told the same story to investigators.

  • Buddy Check 3

    Learn more about Buddy Check and sign up to get a reminder to perform a self-exam and remind your friends to do the same.

  • Jack in Madison

    Jack in Madison

    Your pet photos

    Email us a picture of you and your pet and we'll use it in out Pet Walk segment which airs every weekday morning at 6:40. Include your name, your pet's name and where you're from. Email to

  • Time for Kids - Explore the Outdoors

    Dean Clinic and WISC-TV3 are focusing on a year-long campaign to get kids off their electronics and into the outdoors.