Madison
14° F
Light Snow
Light Snow
Advertisement

Pair suing in birth control swap can’t get child-rearing costs

Published On: Jan 30 2013 11:06:09 AM CST
Birth control pills file 2

iStock/meltonmedia

MADISON, Wis. -

A state appeals court said a West Bend couple can't recoup the costs of raising a child they conceived after a clinic mistakenly gave the mother vitamins instead of birth control pills.

Shelby Nell and Austin Omernick alleged West Bend Clinic filled Nell's birth control prescription with prenatal vitamins. She got pregnant before she realized the mistake and gave birth to a healthy boy in 2009.

The couple sued the clinic in 2010, seeking damages related to pain and suffering during the pregnancy and the cost of raising the child to age 18.

The 2nd District Court of Appeals ruled Wednesday the couple can't collect the cost of raising the boy, and said such a claim raises too many avenues for fraud. The couple can seek damages for suffering, however.

Advertisement
  • Mil debate media gallery main

    Win McNamee/Getty Images

    Clinton, Sanders face off in Milwaukee debate

    Democratic presidential candidates Sen. Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton participate in the PBS NewsHour Democratic presidential candidate debate at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee in Milwaukee. The debate is the final debate before the Nevada caucuses scheduled for Feb. 20.

  • Wildlife refuge

    CNN

    Oregon armed protesters: What to know

    A 41-day occupation at a federal wildlife refuge in Oregon ended Thursday when the four remaining protesters surrendered to authorities. Here is what to you need to know about the group.

  • Titanic II

    Blue Star Line

    Titanic II: A look inside

    The new Titanic II will be practically identical to the original luxury liner, which famously sank in April 1912 after striking an iceberg on its maiden voyage. Here's a look inside the ocean liner, which is slated to sail in 2018.

  • Audrey

    Audrey

    Look Who's 3

    Check out who's turning 3, and send in your photo.

  • Valentine's Day card

    Valentine's Day

    Gift ideas, getting in the mood, popping the question, recipes and ideas for kids, all in our special section dedicated to Valentine's Day.

  • heart--stethoscope--doctor--medical---21654271

    Healthy Heart

    Tips to stay heart healthy, reducing your risk of heart disease, advice and the latest research on heart health.

Advertisement