82° F
Scattered Clouds
Scattered Clouds

Jury heads to second day of deliberation in Chad Chritton trial

Published On: Mar 15 2013 01:13:35 AM CDT   Updated On: Mar 15 2013 07:39:36 AM CDT
Chad Chritton

The jury has not yet reached a verdict in the trial of the father accused of starving and abusing his 16-year-old daughter.

The trial against 41-year-old Chad Chritton was sent to the jury for a decision Thursday in Dane County Circuit Court. He faces five felony child abuse charges and one misdemeanor charge.

Dane County District Attorney Matthew Moeser told jurors Thursday the man hid his daughter in his basement so people wouldn't ask questions. Moeser said the girl didn't know what day or month it was.

The girl, who in court records is referred to as "SLC," weighed 68 pounds when she ran away from the home in February 2012 and was discovered by a passing motorist.

During closing arguments, Moeser said Chritton didn't try to get help for the girl, and recounted the timeline of events in the case and the witnesses the jury heard from over the past two weeks.

"Starvation ends in death, and that's where SLC was heading," Moeser said. "The defendant endangered SLC's safety by engaging in criminal misconduct to deprive her of food."

Moeser said the abuse was punishment for a threat Chritton's daughter made years ago.

"When does confining a child in the basement stop being reasonable discipline? When does it simply become another form of abusing that child or causing that child mental harm?" Moeser asked the jury.

In closing, Moeser recalled the victim's testimony about the mold-covered mattress she slept on as she was locked in a basement for years.

Chritton's attorney, William Hayes, cast doubt on SLC's testimony and said her stories about how she was treated changed numerous times.

He said Chritton repeatedly asked authorities for help with SLC, and that Chritton was doing what he could to help his daughter, who has diagnosed mental health issues. There was no credible evidence that SLC was ever locked in the family's basement, according to Hayes.

"It's her mental illness, her mental problems, and that's why she's doing what she's doing," Hayes said.

The defense said the girl had adequate food and clothing available, but chose not to dress appropriately or eat well.

Hayes told the jury that it can only begin considering a guilty verdict if it believes everything SLC said.

Hayes argued that SLC was a problem child that Chritton couldn't control.

  • Buddy Check 3

    Learn more about Buddy Check and sign up to get a reminder to perform a self-exam and remind your friends to do the same.

  • Jack in Madison

    Jack in Madison

    Your pet photos

    Email us a picture of you and your pet and we'll use it in out Pet Walk segment which airs every weekday morning at 6:40. Include your name, your pet's name and where you're from. Email to

  • Time for Kids - Explore the Outdoors

    Dean Clinic and WISC-TV3 are focusing on a year-long campaign to get kids off their electronics and into the outdoors.