76° F
Mostly Cloudy
Mostly Cloudy

Reality Check: Third-Party Ad Attacks Assembly Candidates On Health Care

Published On: Oct 22 2008 09:28:48 AM CDT
Updated On: Oct 22 2008 09:31:18 AM CDT

While the state's attention has been trained on the presidential race, local Assembly races are heating up and taking to the airwaves.

VIDEO: Watch The Report

A third-party ad is sparking controversy, and a WISC-TV "Reality Check" finds that the health care claims aren't all what they seem.

Health care is the focus of an ad by a special interest group trying to link two Assembly candidates to a health care plan proposed last year.

The group running the ad is the Coalition for America's Families, a Wisconsin branch of a Virginia-based conservative group.

Its director is Barbara Sellett, an advocate for educational reform. It was formerly chaired by the current national committeeman for the state Republican Party.

The group said it "promotes policies that reduce tax burdens on families." It doesn't list its members or donors publicly.

"Welcome to Wisconsin. Free health care for illegal aliens! Free for non-residents!" the ad says.

WISC-TV found this claim misleading.

The ad is referring to the Healthy Wisconsin Plan, passed by the Senate last year. The program aims to provide health care to everyone in the state at low cost, not free.

The plan would involve a deductible of $300 for individuals, $600 for families and a co-pay for most medical care. The state's working residents would also pay for it in an increased payroll tax.

It's true that illegal immigrants or non-residents could be eligible, if they have jobs in the state. The program said those who work in Wisconsin but don't live here would qualify for coverage, along with their families. But they'd pay for it in their Wisconsin payroll taxes.

The ad says: "This is kind of like that idea of giving Wisconsin welfare checks to people from Illinois. Only a lot better."

While this has nothing to do with the health care plan, it's another controversy the state faced over services nearly two decades ago.

Republicans claimed the state was a "welfare magnet," bringing Illinois residents here to take advantage of the state's program.

It was the impetus for the state's W-2 program, a revamped welfare system that required people to be working or in school to be eligible.

"Trish O'Neil and John Waelti's government-run health care plan means higher taxes," the ad says.

This claim is misleading, WISC-TV found.

Healthy Wisconsin was neither Trish O'Neil's nor John Waelti's health care plan. Neither held office when the plan was developed.

Second, the ad shows an increase in taxes of $510 per worker.

But actually, under Healthy Wisconsin the average worker would pay $140 a month in additional payroll taxes. Their employer would pay another $370 on their behalf.

Both of these Assembly candidates said they support a plan providing affordable and accessible health care. Neither of them during this campaign has professed support for Healthy Wisconsin in its present form.

  • Kenneth Bae, Matthew Miller, Jeffrey Fowle


    Who are 3 Americans detained in North Korea?

    Matthew Todd Miller, a 24-year-old from California, has been convicted of "acts hostile" to North Korea and sentenced to six years of hard labor. Learn more about the three Americans currently being detained in North Korea.

  • iOS 8

    From Apple

    Best new Apple iOS 8 features

    Apple's iOS 8 is here, and it's packed with slick new features. Take a look at some of the best changes to the latest version of the popular mobile operating system.

  • Testing for Ebola

    REUTERS/Misha Hussain

    Common myths about Ebola

    At least eight Ebola aid workers and journalists were reportedly murdered in a remote village in Guinea in a brutal example of growing distrust locals have of foreigners coming to help stem the mushrooming health crisis. Take a look at common myths about the deadly virus.


    Events calendar

    Looking for something to do? Visit Channel 3000's events section featuring dining, food, music and family-friendly events throughout Madison and the surrounding area.

  • Get your weather app and WISC-TV3 deliver local forecasts, live radar, school closings and alerts for Madison and South Central Wisconsin to iOS or Android devices.

  • Learn more about WISC-TV

    Meet the News 3 staff, learn about our newscasts, search our job postings and find out how to contact us.