45° F
Light Drizzle
Light Drizzle

Reality Check: McCain-Feingold Campaign Finance Reform

Published On: Oct 18 2004 03:01:21 AM CDT   Updated On: Oct 18 2004 04:01:56 AM CDT

Since the last federal election, there have been some changes in election law, such as the McCain-Feingold Campaign Finance Reform. Both of Wisconsin's U.S. Senate candidates, Senator Russ Feingold and Tim Michels, are trying to explain their views of it through TV ads. News 3 helps make sense of it in our Reality Check series.

If there's one piece of legislation Russ Feingold is famous for, it's campaign finance reform. After all, he and John McCain authored and campaigned for it. Now, he's defending it with a TV ad.

But, let's start with Republican challenger Tim Michels' critique in his TV ad.

The ad, narrated by Michels, states, "Every time you hear, 'I approve this message,' thank Russ Feingold. He spent 12 years fighting for campaign finance reform. Now every politician has to say, 'I approve this message.' Wow, 12 years for eight words. Has that really helped us in Wisconsin?"

This is misleading. The McCain-Feingold Campaign Finance Reform bill included much more than the "stand by your ad" provision, which Michels' labels as simply "eight words."

First of all, the bill was introduced in 1995 and signed in 2002, so it took seven years to pass, not 12. It does require candidates to say something like "I approved this message," but it did much more. It banned so-called "soft money" to the national parties. Soft money is unregulated and unlimited cash the parties used to raise and spend in the millions.

"Special interest groups would give $500,000 or $1,000,000 contributions on a Tuesday. Then, on a Wednesday or Thursday, in a key committee in Congress, they would have a special break provided to them," said Jay Heck, of Common Cause in Wisconsin, a non-partisan reform advocate.

The bill also bans so-called "issue ads." The ads attacked a candidate without using his or her name. That's now illegal 60 days before the general election.

Corporations and unions can still buy ads through non-profit groups, but the source of the money must be disclosed.

"And that's important because that way, people know who's paying for these ads and the money's coming from regulated sources," Heck said.

Michels makes the argument at the end of his ad that Feingold's time on this issue would have been better spent on issues that, in his view, directly affect Wisconsinites like health care.

Feingold has said he can do both and that's up to the voter to decide.

Senator Feingold, in his ad, has a drastically different view of campaign finance.

"Big money corporation versus the average American citizen," Feingold said.

In his ad, Feingold points to health care where, in his view, special interests always seem to win.

"All because there wasn't a level playing field. But thanks to the passage of the McCain-Feingold bill, unlimited contributions like these, that are little more than bribes, are now illegal," Feingold said.

The dollars he kicked out in his TV ad represent soft money to the political parties. It's true that are now illegal, but there's more to campaign finance reform.

The bill has legitimate critics. For example, some opponents believe that political money will always find its way into the system. Before McCain-Feingold, unlimited donations flowed freely to political parties and directly into the system. But blocking this, the theory goes, creates other holes like the 527s.

The now infamous Swift Boat ads, or all the ads by, are non-profit groups intended to influence the election - 527s in the federal tax code. A lot of money has shifted to those groups. Many call it a loophole.

McCain and Feingold unsuccessfully asked the Federal Elections Commission to regulate the groups. They then introduced legislation that would regulate the unlimited donations, but it won't have any effect on this election.

The bottom line is that campaign finance reform is working in some areas and a work in progress in others. Where the candidates disagree is whether or not it's worth working on at all.

  • PHOTOS: Vilas Zoo announces new holiday lights exhibit

    The Henry Vilas Zoo will light up nights this holiday season with its new Zoo Lights event. The Zoo Lights exhibit will offer zoo-goers a stroll down Candy Cane Lane with festive lights and sounds. Zoo organizers announced the Zoo Light exhibit Wednesday and said thousands of lights will transform the zoo into a winter wonderland Nov. 25-Jan. 1.

    Admission is $7 and Zoo Lights will run Thursdays through Sundays beginning at 5:30 p.m.

  • Takata air bag recall by the numbers - blurb

    Joe Raedle/Getty Images

    Takata air bag recall by the numbers

    Millions of cars have been recalled due to defective Takata air bags across the world. One in every 10 cars in the U.S. is affected by the recall, Automotive News reports. The publication is calling this the "recall of the century," as up to 90 million more recalls are possible.

  • Syrian refugees 11

    Philipp Guelland/Getty Images

    Europe refugee crisis: 2016 'deadliest year'

    France continues to clear out "The Jungle," and the UN refuge agency says 2016 has become the deadliest for migrants crossing the Mediterranean bound for Europe. Here is look at the latest developments in the European refuge crisis.